top of page
Writer's pictureAdmin

Cat Fines in Ship Bunkers: The Silent Threat to Ship Engines

A recent study by the International Bunker Industry Association (IBIA) reveals that 80% of ship engine failures are linked to cat fines in marine fuel oil. These tiny particles are introduced into ship bunkers during the refining process. They pose a significant risk to the longevity and performance of ship engines.


A ship's E/R with various machinery & piping
A ship's E/R with various machinery & piping

The abrasive nature of cat fines can cause excessive wear on critical engine components. This wear leads to reduced efficiency, increased maintenance costs, and even catastrophic failures. As the maritime industry strives to meet stricter emissions regulations and adopt cleaner bunker fuel, the problem of cat fines contamination becomes more urgent.


The CIMAC Fuel Oil Recommendation No. 21 outlines guidelines for petroleum fuels in marine and stationary diesel engines. It categorizes fuel properties based on their impact on fuel cleaning systems and the cleaning process. Despite these guidelines, the challenge of cat fines in ship bunkers remains a significant issue for ship operators and engineers.


Key Takeaways:

  • Cat fines are a major cause of ship engine failures, responsible for up to 80% of incidents

  • These abrasive particles enter ship bunkers during the refining process and can cause severe damage to engine components

  • The presence of cat fines in marine fuel oil leads to reduced efficiency, increased maintenance costs, and potential catastrophic failures

  • The CIMAC Fuel Oil Recommendation No. 21 provides guidelines for fuel properties, but the issue of cat fines persists

  • As the maritime industry faces stricter emissions regulations, addressing fuel oil contamination by cat fines becomes increasingly critical


Understanding Cat Fines in Marine Fuel Oil

The emergence of catalytic fines, or cat fines, has become a pressing issue for ship operators and engineers. As the global shipping industry transitioned to low-sulfur fuels, grasping the essence and effects of cat fines is imperative. This knowledge is vital for preserving engine efficiency and durability.


What are Catalytic Fines?

Catalytic fines, commonly referred to as cat fines, are minute, abrasive particles that stem from the fluid catalytic cracking (FCC) process in oil refineries. These particles, ranging from 10 to 80 microns in size, possess a density slightly above that of heavy fuel oil (HFO). Remarkably, cat fines are extremely hard, with a Mohs hardness of up to 8.2, rivaling diamond's 10.


The inclusion of cat fines in marine fuel oil is an unintended byproduct of the refining process. As refineries process heavier crude oils to fulfill the increasing demand for low-sulfur fuels, the likelihood of cat fines contamination in ship bunkers escalates significantly.


The table below shows the most common cat fines found in ship bunkers & their relative limits, according to ISO 8217:2005 standards:


Cat Fine

Max Limit (ISO 8217:2005 Standards)

Iron

60 - 80 ppm (recommended)

Sodium

< 50 ppm (recommended)

Vanadium

300 ppm

Aluminum plus Silicon

80 ppm

Calcium

30 ppm

Phosphorus

15 ppm

Zinc

15 ppm


A typical analysis report is shown in the picture below:


A typical bunker analysis report
A typical bunker analysis report

How Cat Fines Enter Ship Bunkers

Cat fines can inadvertently contaminate ship bunkers during the blending and transportation of marine fuel oils. The International Maritime Organization's (IMO) 2020 Sulphur Cap has heightened concerns regarding the potential rise in cat fines content in marine fuels. This shift to cleaner, low-sulfur fuels is a primary cause.


A ship's engineer carefully extracting a sample of fuel oil from a storage tank
A ship's engineer carefully extracting a sample of fuel oil from a storage tank

Marine fuel oil must comply with the international standard ISO 8217, which restricts cat fine concentration in bunker fuel. Yet, manufacturers such as MAN and Wärtsilä advocate for fuel with more strict cat fine concentrations, to avert engine damage.


Refineries advised on a maximum combined level of aluminium and silicon in fuel deliveries of 60mg/kg to minimize risk.

The presence of cat fines in ship bunkers represents a substantial threat to engine performance and longevity. It is critical to comprehend the nature and impact of these abrasive particles. This understanding is essential for devising effective fuel management strategies in the low-sulfur era.


The Damaging Effects of Cat Fines on Ship Engines

Cat fines in ship bunkers pose a significant threat to the health and longevity of ship engines. These abrasive particles, when not effectively removed from the fuel oil, can cause extensive cat fines engine damage. This damage leads to costly repairs and downtime. It is crucial for ship operators and engineers to understand these effects to implement proper preventive measures.


Abrasive Wear on Engine Components

The hard and abrasive nature of cat fines can cause accelerated wear on critical engine components. These include fuel injectors, piston rings, and cylinder liners. Over time, this wear leads to decreased engine performance, increased fuel consumption, and even catastrophic engine failures. Statistics show that vessels typically suffer between one to two incidences of main engine damage during their lifetime. The average claims cost is around USD 650,000.


Engine Component

Potential Damage

Fuel Injectors

Nozzle erosion, reduced fuel atomization

Piston Rings

Accelerated wear, increased blow-by

Cylinder Liners

Scoring, increased oil consumption


Clogged Fuel Filters and Reduced Efficiency

Cat fines can obstruct fuel filters, leading to decreased fuel flow and additional engine inefficiencies. The updated International Marine Fuel Standard, ISO 8217:2017, sets stringent limits for cat fines in fuel supplied to ships.


However, bunker samples from around the globe have shown high levels of cat fines, making it very challenging to lower these levels to acceptable engine entry standards using only the ship's filters.


Therefore, employing shipboard equipment like centrifugal separators becomes essential to further reduce cat fine levels.



ISO 8217 Standards and Cat Fines

The ISO 8217 fuel standards are pivotal in maintaining marine fuel quality and engine performance. These standards dictate specific fuel oil quality requirements, including the maximum allowable cat fines levels in marine fuel oil.

ISO 8217:2017 sets the maximum cat fines limit in marine residual fuels. Yet, even fuels meeting this standard can still risk engine damage if cat fines are not effectively removed by onboard fuel treatment systems.


The marine industry has seen a notable increase in cat fines levels in fuels, largely due to international sulfur content regulations. This has resulted in fuel oil pollution incidents causing significant engine damage and power loss, disrupting ship's itineraries & causing financial losses to ship owners.


A complex mechanical assembly with visible signs of wear

To counteract these risks, ship operators must commit to regular fuel testing and ensure the effectiveness of onboard fuel treatment systems.


To safeguard ship engine longevity and performance, operators must prioritize regular fuel testing, maintain treatment system efficiency, and collaborate with dependable fuel suppliers. Suppliers should consistently provide marine fuels that meet ISO 8217 marine fuel specifications.


Detecting and Measuring Cat Fines in Ship Bunkers

Accurate detection of cat fines is paramount for the longevity and efficiency of ship engines. The role of fuel oil sampling and testing in monitoring cat fines levels cannot be overstated. It is crucial for preventing engine damage. Let's examine the essential components of detecting and measuring cat fines in ship bunkers.


Sampling and Testing Methods

Accurate fuel sampling techniques are indispensable for obtaining representative samples for cat fines analysis.


After collecting the samples, various cat fines testing methods are employed to quantify these abrasive particles:

  • inductively coupled plasma (ICP) spectroscopy, and

  • optical microscopy


, are commonly used techniques for determining cat fines content in fuel oil samples.


Interpreting Cat Fine Analysis Results

Interpreting cat fine analysis results is vital for evaluating fuel quality and making informed decisions regarding fuel treatment and engine maintenance. Key considerations include:

  • Comparing cat fines levels against industry standards, such as the ISO 8217 specification, to ensure compliance and minimize engine wear.

  • Monitoring trends in cat fines concentrations over time to identify potential issues with fuel suppliers or onboard fuel treatment systems.

  • Assessing the effectiveness of settling tanks, centrifugal separators, and filtration systems in reducing cat fines levels before fuel reaches the engine.


By regularly conducting fuel analysis and interpreting the results, ship operators can proactively address cat fines-related issues and optimize engine performance. Effective cat fines detection  and monitoring practices are essential for extending engine life, reducing maintenance costs, and ensuring the smooth operation of maritime vessels.


Onboard Fuel Treatment Systems for Cat Fines Removal

Effective fuel treatment is essential for eliminating cat fines and safeguarding ship engines from their harmful effects. Modern fuel treatment systems integrate various stages to guarantee fuel purity and enhance engine performance. These systems encompass settling tanks, centrifugal separators, filtration, and fuel conditioning components.


Settling Tanks and Centrifugal Separators

The fuel treatment process commences with settling tanks, where heavier contaminants, including cat fines, settle out of the fuel oil due to gravity. These tanks are designed to provide sufficient residence time for the fuel. This allows denser particles to accumulate at the bottom for periodic removal.


A ship's engine room piping with signs of oil stains and corroded metal surfaces
A ship's engine room piping with signs of oil stains and corroded metal surfaces

Centrifugal separators  follow as the next stage in the fuel treatment process. These devices utilize centrifugal force to separate cat fines and other contaminants from the fuel oil. The high rotational speed of the separator generates a strong centrifugal force. This force causes denser particles to move outward, while the cleaner fuel remains in the center. Centrifugal separators are highly effective at removing the majority of cat fines from the fuel.


Filtration and Fuel Conditioning

Following the settling tanks and centrifugal separators, the fuel undergoes fine filtration to remove any remaining contaminants. High-efficiency fuel filters with small pore sizes are employed to capture even the smallest cat fines particles. This ensures the fuel meets the required cleanliness standards.


Fuel conditioning systems are also utilized to maintain the quality and stability of the fuel. These systems may include fuel heating, viscosity control, and additives to prevent sludge formation and improve combustion properties. Proper fuel conditioning optimizes engine performance and reduces the risk of fuel-related issues.


"Cat fines are typically less than 10 micrometers in diameter, making them difficult to detect and remove through conventional filtration systems."

Best Practices for Managing Cat Fines in Ship Bunkers

Effective cat fines management is essential for the longevity and health of ship engines. Implementing best practices from bunker fuel purchasing to onboard fuel handling and storage minimizes engine damage risks. This approach ensures the longevity and efficiency of ship engines.


Bunker Fuel Purchasing and Supplier Selection

Choosing reputable suppliers for bunker fuel is critical. They must provide high-quality, low-cat-fines fuel oils. Reputable bunker suppliers often help to ensure better fuel quality and less risk to machinery.


When selecting a fuel supplier, consider the following:

  • Compliance with the latest ISO 8217 standards

  • Proven track record of delivering low-cat-fines fuel

  • Transparent fuel quality testing and reporting

  • Competitive pricing without compromising fuel quality


Onboard Fuel Handling and Storage Procedures

Proper onboard fuel handling and storage procedures are crucial. They minimize cat fines accumulation and ensure optimal fuel quality. Key steps include:

  1. Maintaining correct settling tank temperatures to promote cat fines settling

  2. Regularly cleaning fuel tanks to remove accumulated cat fines

  3. Ensuring proper operation and maintenance of centrifugal separators

  4. Implementing a robust fuel filtration system with appropriate mesh sizes

  5. Conducting regular fuel sampling and testing to monitor cat fines levels


Emerging Technologies for Cat Fines Mitigation

The maritime industry is actively seeking innovative solutions to combat the detrimental effects of cat fines on ship engines. Advanced cat fines mitigation technologies are being developed. These technologies aim to improve fuel quality and reduce engine damage caused by catalytic fines.


Electrostatic precipitators are a promising technology. They use high-voltage electrodes to charge and remove cat fines particles from the fuel. This method provides an additional layer of protection, significantly reducing the concentration of cat fines entering the engine.


Magnetic fuel conditioning is another area of research for cat fines mitigation. This technology involves exposing fuel to strong magnetic fields. It alters the physical properties of cat fines particles, making them easier to remove through conventional filtration methods. This could improve separator efficiency and overall fuel quality.


Researchers are also exploring nanotechnology fuel additives to address cat fines. These additives can modify the surface properties of cat fines particles. They prevent agglomeration and facilitate removal through existing filtration systems. Nanotechnology-based solutions may also reduce abrasive wear on engine components.


Cat fines are certain to be present in new fuel blends produced post-2020, including renewable fuels. The industry must adapt and embrace innovative technologies to address this persistent challenge.

As the maritime sector transitions to new fuel blends post-2020, including renewable fuels, cat fines will remain a significant concern. Adopting these emerging technologies, along with best practices, will be crucial. Regular testing, monitoring, and servicing of equipment are essential to mitigate cat fines' impact on ship engines. This ensures optimal performance and reliability.


Case Studies: Cat Fines Related Engine Failures

Lessons Learned from Real-World Incidents

Examining the causes of cat fines-related engine failures provides valuable lessons. Ship owners and operators can enhance their fuel management practices. This prevents similar incidents in their fleets. Key takeaways include:

  • Implementing stringent fuel purchasing and supplier selection criteria to ensure high-quality bunkers with minimal cat fines content

  • Conducting regular fuel testing at various stages, from bunkering to engine entry, to monitor cat fines levels and take corrective actions promptly

  • Optimizing onboard fuel treatment systems, such as settling tanks, centrifugal separators, and filtration units, to effectively remove cat fines and maintain fuel cleanliness

  • Providing comprehensive training to crew members on proper fuel handling, storage, and treatment procedures to minimize the risk of contamination and ensure optimal engine performance


By learning from these case studies and implementing preventative measures, ship owners and operators can significantly reduce the likelihood of cat fines-related engine failures. This minimizes operational disruptions, costly repairs, and potential safety hazards.


Conclusion

Cat fines in ship bunkers pose a substantial challenge to the marine industry, threatening engine reliability and vessel performance. These microscopic particles, mainly composed of aluminum and silicon oxides, can cause abrasive wear on critical engine components. This wear leads to reduced efficiency and potential failures. As the maritime sector adapts to stricter environmental regulations, such as the IMO 2020 Sulphur Cap, the need for effective fuel management and protecting ship engines from cat fines becomes more apparent.


To address the risks of cat fines, the industry must adopt a proactive stance. Adherence to ISO 8217 standards, which outline maximum allowable concentrations of aluminum and silicon in marine fuels, is vital. Advanced detection methods, such as ICP and XRF spectroscopy, alongside onboard fuel treatment systems, aid in identifying and removing cat fines from bunker fuel. Emerging technologies, like AI-integrated fuel monitoring systems and LIBS, hold promise for enhancing cat fines detection and prevention.


The maritime industry must prioritize fuel management importance and implement best practices for bunker fuel purchasing, handling, and storage. Staying informed about the latest cat fines mitigation developments and sharing real-world incident lessons is crucial. A comprehensive approach to managing cat fines will enhance engine reliability, reduce maintenance costs, and ensure safer, more efficient vessel operations amidst evolving marine industry challenges.


FAQ

What are cat fines, and why are they a concern for ship engines?

Cat fines, or catalytic fines, are hard, abrasive particles that can contaminate ship bunkers during oil refining. These particles, mainly composed of aluminum and silicon oxides, can severely damage engine components. This damage can lead to reduced efficiency and potential engine failures if not removed from the fuel oil effectively.


How do cat fines enter ship bunkers?

Cat fines are a byproduct of the fluid catalytic cracking (FCC) process in oil refineries. This process breaks down heavy oils into lighter, more valuable products. The hard, ceramic particles can accidentally enter ship bunkers during the blending and transportation of marine fuel oils.


What are the damaging effects of cat fines on ship engines?

Cat fines can cause accelerated wear on critical engine components like fuel injectors, piston rings, and cylinder liners. This wear can decrease engine performance, increase fuel consumption, and even lead to catastrophic engine failures. Cat fines can also clog fuel filters, reducing fuel flow and causing further inefficiencies.


What are the ISO 8217 standards for cat fines in marine fuel?

The International Organization for Standardization (ISO) has established ISO 8217 to specify marine fuel requirements, including cat fines limits. The current ISO 8217:2017 sets a maximum cat fines limit of 60 mg/kg (ppm) in marine residual fuels.


How are cat fines detected and measured in ship bunkers?

Detecting and measuring cat fines in ship bunkers is crucial for preventing engine damage. Proper fuel sampling techniques, such as continuous drip sampling or manual sampling, ensure representative samples. Cat fines content is determined using laboratory methods like inductively coupled plasma (ICP) spectroscopy or optical microscopy.


What onboard fuel treatment systems are used to remove cat fines?

Effective onboard fuel treatment is essential for removing cat fines and protecting ship engines. The process starts with settling tanks, where contaminants settle out of the fuel oil. Centrifugal separators then remove most cat fines using centrifugal force. Fine filtration and fuel conditioning systems further polish the fuel, ensuring it meets cleanliness standards before entering the engine.


What are the best practices for managing cat fines in ship bunkers?

To minimize cat fines-related engine damage, a proactive fuel management approach is necessary. Selecting reputable suppliers who provide high-quality, low-cat-fines fuel oils is crucial. Proper fuel handling and storage procedures, such as maintaining correct settling tank temperatures and regularly cleaning tanks, can prevent cat fines accumulation.


What emerging technologies are being developed to mitigate cat fines in marine fuel?

New technologies are emerging to enhance fuel treatment and reduce engine damage from cat fines. Electrostatic precipitators, which use high-voltage electrodes to charge and remove particles, show promise. Magnetic fuel conditioning systems and nanotechnology-based fuel additives are also being explored to improve fuel quality and mitigate cat fines' impact on ship engines.

Comments


bottom of page