Have you ever wondered how the weight of cargo on ships is determined? It's all about the ship draft survey. But what exactly is it, and how is it conducted? This guide will delve into the specifics of marine draft surveys, discussing essential concepts, methods, and recommended practices.
A ship draft survey measures cargo weight by comparing the ship's weight before and after loading. It's based on Archimedes' law, but the process is complex. Factors like the ship's shape and weather conditions play a role. It requires a deep understanding of the vessel and precise measurements.
In this article, we'll walk you through the ship draft survey process. You'll learn about preparation, reading draft marks, calculating ballast, and more. Mastering these techniques ensures accurate cargo weight measurements and avoids disputes.
Whether you're a marine surveyor, ship officer, or just generally interested in this topic, this guide will help you understand the basics of conducting a proper ship draft survey. It's packed with the knowledge and skills needed for reliable vessel draft measurements. Let's dive into the world of ship cargo weight determination.
Key Takeaways
Ship draft surveys calculate cargo weight by measuring the difference in ship weight before and after loading.
Factors like ship shape, hogging and sagging, and weather conditions can complicate the process.
Accurate draft mark readings, ballast calculations, and corrections are crucial for reliable results.
Proper documentation and evidence collection can help prevent disputes over cargo measurements.
Mastering draft survey techniques is essential for marine surveyors and ship officers to ensure precise cargo weight determination.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational purposes only and should not be considered as professional advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and completeness of the information presented, we make no guarantees and assume no liability for any errors or omissions. Draft surveys should only be conducted by trained and certified professionals. Always consult with a qualified expert before undertaking any draft survey procedures.
Understanding the Purpose of a Draft Survey
A ship draft survey is crucial for accurately measuring cargo loaded or unloaded. It measures the vessel's displacement before and after cargo operations. This method ensures the correct cargo delivery and prevents disputes between ship owners and charterers.
Draft surveys are essential in the shipping industry for safety and efficiency. Inaccurate calculations can lead to severe consequences, as seen in the MV Rocknes incident in 2004. This tragedy highlights the need for precise draft surveys to prevent such accidents.
Determining Cargo Quantity
The main goal of a draft survey is to measure cargo quantity. By comparing the vessel's displacement before and after cargo transfer, surveyors can accurately calculate cargo weight. Draft surveys offer a net cargo weight accuracy of ± 0.5%, making them reliable for cargo measurement.
Method | Accuracy |
Weighbridges | 0.5% to 1.0% |
Conveyor belt weigh scales | 0.125 - 0.5% |
Draft surveys | ± 0.5% |
Archimedes' Principle and Draft Surveys
Draft surveys use Archimedes' principle to measure cargo weight. This principle states that the buoyant force on an object is equal to the fluid displaced. By measuring the vessel's draft before and after cargo operation, draft surveyors can determine the cargo weight.
Archimedes' principle is the foundation of draft surveys, enabling surveyors to accurately determine the weight of cargo loaded or unloaded from a vessel by measuring the change in the vessel's displacement.
Preventing Disputes with Clear Contractual Terms
Accurate draft surveys prevent disputes between ship owners and charterers. Clear contractual terms for cargo measurement reduce the risk of disagreements. There is a 'commonly accepted' 0.5% error margin, but there is no industry-agreed discrepancy or shortage allowance for dry bulk cargoes.
To ensure accurate draft surveys, it's vital to use well-trained inspectors with a marine background. Proper documentation and equipment should be prepared in advance. Weather conditions, currents, and tides also impact measurement accuracy.
Key Concepts and Definitions
To accurately conduct a draft survey, it's crucial to grasp the foundational concepts. These include lightship weight, ship constants, and the effects of hogging and sagging in ships.
Lightship Weight
The lightship weight is the ship's weight at construction, including engine and cargo space, but not crew or cargo. It's vital for calculating the ship's constants and cargo weight during a draft survey.
In theory, lightship weight remains constant throughout the ship's entire lifecycle. However, in reality lightship weight can increase by about 0.2% annually, due to adding paint layers on hull, tanks & equipment, equipment modifications or retrofits, and tank mud accumulation.
Constant and Its Variability
The constant in draft survey is the difference between the calculated lightship weight and the ship's book figures at a specific time. It changes due to structural, equipment, or weight changes (due to spare parts onboard, stores & provisions, etc).
Verifying the declared constant is key for draft survey accuracy. Surveyors must use approved hydrostatic data and consider any modifications or refits that affect the ship's measurements.
Hogging and Sagging
Hogging and sagging are phenomena that can distort draft survey readings. Hogging happens when the ship's ends are heavier than the middle, bending it upwards. Sagging occurs when the middle is heavier, bending it downwards.
Understanding these concepts ensures precise draft surveys. This minimizes cargo quantity disputes.
A Guide for Preparing for the Draft Survey
Before starting a draft survey, it's crucial to use a detailed draft survey checklist. This ensures the survey's accuracy and avoids potential disputes. The preparation involves checking the ship's constant, examining its condition, and collecting the necessary draft readings (fwd, mid & aft).
Tools to be used
Key draft survey equipment includes (but not limited to):
Laptop (for in-situ calculations & report generation)
Notebook & pen
Sounding Tape (both ballast & bunker tapes)
Sounding paste (water & fuel paste, a popular brand is 'Kolor Kut')
Plain measuring Tape
Laser Thermometer (& spare batteries)
Chalks
Petroleum ASTM Table 54B (for Fuel Oil) and Table 56
Safety Protection: Hat, Goggles and Gloves
Flashlight (Torch)
Seawater Sampling Can (Bucket)
Check Constants
Start by comparing the declared constant with the calculated one from previous surveys. Note any discrepancies or trends. Make sure all tables and hydrostatic data are class-approved. Any changes or big retrofits (e.g installing a ballast water system), must have been properly documented.
Record ship's list (heel) & trim
The ship's list (heel) should be recorded by using a calibrated inclinometer. Also, the trim can be easily calculated from the draft readings taken in step (2). No changes in list or trim should occur during the survey, so it needs to be verified with Chief Officer that no bunkering or cargo operations will take place during the draft survey.
"Proper draft survey preparation is the foundation of an accurate and reliable survey. It is crucial to follow best practices and ensure all necessary steps are taken before the survey begins."
Preparation Step | Importance |
Verify ship's constant | Ensure accuracy and identify anomalies |
Check ship's condition | Prevent issues with trim and list |
Gather essential equipment | Facilitate accurate measurements |
Ensure clear draft marks | Enable precise readings |
Accurately Reading Draft Marks
Ensuring precise reading of draft marks is crucial for conducting an accurate ship draft survey. Even minor inaccuracies can lead to significant discrepancies in cargo quantities. A well-conducted draft survey of a large vessel should achieve accuracy within 0.5%, but challenges such as parallax error or wave interference can hinder this goal.
How to Conduct a Ship Draft Survey: A Step-by-Step Process
Conducting a ship draft survey is a critical process. It involves several key steps to accurately determine the vessel's weight and cargo quantity. By following these steps meticulously, surveyors can ensure the safety and compliance of the ship. They also prevent disputes over cargo quantities.
Step 1. Measuring Water Density & Temperature
Water density plays a significant role in draft surveys. It directly impacts the ship's draft. Surveyors must measure the density of the water in which the ship is floating. Sea water typically has a density of 1.025, while fresh water has a density of 1.000, but an accurate recording of density is crucial.
The sea water density also needs to be recorded by taking a sample (usually at 1/2 of water depth) & then using a certified & calibrated hydrometer.
Seawater temperature also needs to be recorded by using a calibrated laser gun.
Accurate dock water density measurement is vital for a precise draft survey and vessel displacement calculation. Water density varies due to factors like salinity, temperature, and contaminants. Thus, using calibrated hydrometers designed for draft surveys is crucial for reliable results.
Surveyors must be aware of water density fluctuations in ports. These can be due to heavy rainfall, tidal forces, or depth variations. To address these, water samples should be taken at the forward, aft, and midship sections. These samples should be at about half the ship's draft depth. The average density from these samples will offer a more accurate value.
Using Calibrated Hydrometers
Calibrated hydrometers for draft survey are essential for precise density measurement. Unlike load line hydrometers, draft survey hydrometers do not need temperature corrections.
Step 2. Cross-checking Ballast Tank Soundings
Ensuring the accuracy of ballast tank soundings is crucial. It's important to cross-check & verify Ch/Officer's readings. Sounding of random bunker tank should be conducted.
Step 3. Observing Six Visual Drafts & Apparent (=Visual) Trim
The first step is to observe the six draft marks on the vessel. These marks are located at the forward, midship, and aft positions on both the port and starboard sides. Accurate readings of these drafts are essential for calculating the ship's displacement and determining its weight.
Usually one of the sides (PORT or STBD) will be inaccessible from quay, so other means should be employed to take a reading (e.g use of rescue boat or pilot ladder).
Now, the average visual drafts should be calculated:
Draft(visual FWD) = [ Draft(visual FWD PORT) + Draft(visual FWD STBD) ] / 2
Draft(visual MID) = [ Draft(visual MID PORT) + Draft(visual MID STBD) ] / 2
Draft(visual AFT) = [ Draft(visual AFT PORT) + Draft(visual AFT STBD) ] / 2
Trim(visual) = [ Draft(visual FWD) - Draft(visual AFT) ]
Important: Minimizing Parallax Error
Parallax error is a common issue in draft surveys, occurring when the observer's line of sight is not perpendicular to the draft marks. To minimize this error, draft surveyors should read the draft close to the waterline, which may require the use of a boat.
Important: Using Wave Dampening Tubes and Manometers
Waves can distort draft readings, making it challenging to obtain accurate measurements. To eliminate this issue, wave dampening tubes with small holes and floats inside can be lowered to take readings unaffected by waves.
Alternatively, manometers with long hoses laid across the beam can measure the difference in water level on both sides, providing more precise readings in wavy conditions.
Step 6a. Convert Visual to Perpendicular Drafts
Then, the visual drafts need to be converted to perpendicular drafts. The formula for this is:
Correction Factor Draft(perpendicular AFT) = [ Correction Factor(AFT) * Trim(visual) ] / LBD
Correction Factor Draft(perpendicular FWD) = [ Correction Factor(FWD) * Trim(visual) ] / LBD
, where:
Correction Factor(AFT) : can be found in ship's stability booklet
Correction Factor(FWD) : can be found in ship's stability booklet
LBD = length between visual draft marks (can also be found in ship's stability booklet)
Now, there is an extra rule that needs to be followed, which is:
If the Ship is Trimmed by Stern | |
Correction Factor Draft(perpendicular FWD) | should always be negative (-) |
Correction Factor Draft(perpendicular AFT) | should always be positive (+) |
If the Ship is Trimmed by Head | |
Correction Factor Draft(perpendicular FWD) | should always be positive (+) |
Correction Factor Draft(perpendicular AFT) | should always be negative (-) |
Now it's time to calculate the perpendicular drafts, using the following simple formulas (& respecting the above +- signs, as shown in the previous tables):
Draft(perp. AFT) = Draft(visual AFT) + Correction Factor Draft(perpendicular AFT)
Draft(perp. FWD) = Draft(visual FWD) + Correction Factor Draft(perpendicular FWD)
The mid draft (usually) has no corrections applied (always consult the ship's stability booklet), so:
Draft(perp. MID) = Draft(visual MID)
Step 6b. Calculate True Trim (perpendicular)
Now we can easily calculate the true trim (for perpendicular drafts) by using the following formula:
Trim(perp) =Draft(perp. FWD) - Draft(visual MID)
Step 7. Calculate the Quarter Mean Drafts
The next step is to calculate the quarter mean draft (also called 'mean of means').
Draft(quarter mean) = [6*Draft(perp. MID) + Draft(perp. AFT) + Draft(perp. FWD)] / 8
Step 8. Interpolate LCF & TPC
TPC's & LCF's are always tabulated in ship's hydrostatic tables, for a range of different drafts. However, rarely do the tabulated drafts will match our Draft(quarter mean). For example, ship's tables might looks something like this:
Our Draft(quarter mean) might be = 9.205 mtrs , which is not shown in the above table. In this case, we have to interpolate, using the neighboring values (9.20 mtr & 9.21 mtr), in order to find our TPC & LCF.
Interpolation is a simple mathematical procedure, but can prove challenging if not applied correctly. There are plenty of YouTube videos explaining proper interpolation methods, one of them being the below:
Now that you (hopefully) became an Interpolation Expert, back to our case: for a Draft(quarter mean) = 9.205 mtrs, our TPC = 34.435 & LCF = 3.245
Step 10a. Find the 'initial' Displacement (in mt) from tables
It's time now to find our 'initial' displacement (in metric tons) from the ship's hydrostatic tables (to which further corrections will be applied in the next steps).
Chances are that you will need to interpolate again.
If the ship's tables look like this:
, and our Draft(quarter mean) = 9.205 mtrs, then (by interpolating) we can calculate that:
Displacement(initial) = 29007.50 metric tons
Step 10b. Applying First (1st) Trim Correction (FTC)
Now it is time to apply our First (1st) Trim Correction, or FTC (abbreviated). The formula to calculate FTC is:
FTC = [ (Draft(quarter mean) * LCF * TPC) / LBP ]*100
If the Ship is Trimmed by Stern | |
the LCF sign | remains unchanged |
If the Ship is Trimmed by Head | |
the LCF sign | should be reversed |
Step 11. Calculate MTC's
We need to calculate now MTC1 & MTC2. MTC's are given in ship's hydrostatic tables, however usually interpolation is necessary here too.
MTC1 = MTC at mean draft + 0.5 mtr
MTC2 = MTC at mean draft - 0.5 mtr
For example, if our hydrostatic tables look like this:
, and our mean draft = 9.21 mtr, then:
MTC1 = MTC at draft = 8.71 mtr
MTC2 = MTC at draft = 9.71 mtr
(since the above tables are only a snippet of the actual tables, drafts 8.71 mtr & 9.71 mtr are not shown in the above picture)
Step 12. Calculate δMTC (difference of MTC's)
δMTC is simply the difference between the MTC's:
δMTC = MTC1 - MTC2
This value should always be positive (subtract the lesser value from the larger one)
Step 13. Applying Second (2nd) Trim Correction (STC)
Now it is time to apply our Second (2nd) Trim Correction, or STC (abbreviated).
The formula to calculate STC is:
STC = [ (Trim(perp) * Trim(perp))* 50 * δMTC ] / LBP
This value should always be positive!
Step 14. Applying the first & second corrections (FTC & STC)
We can now calculate the ship's displacement, by taking into account the FTC & STC we just calculated. For this, we use the simple formula:
Displacement(corrected) = Displacement(initial) + FTC + STC
Step 15. Accounting for Sea Water Density
Usually, all hydrostatic table values are given for nominal sea water density:
ρ(nominal) = 1025 kg / m3.
However in reality, the actual sea water density will differ (see previous step 1).
This has to be taken into account & the displacement be corrected (again). For this, following formula can be used:
Displacement(final) = [ Displacement(corrected) * ρ(actual) ] / ρ(nominal)
, where ρ(actual) has been calculated using a hydrometer (see step 1).
Performing Precise Calculations and Applying Corrections
Accurate draft survey calculations are vital for cargo weight determination. Even seasoned surveyors can err when correcting data, due to differing sign conventions. It's crucial to maintain consistent data reference points in calculations.
Understanding Ship-Specific Documentation
Each ship comes with its own hydrostatic tables and documentation. These are essential for draft survey calculations. For instance, the longitudinal center of flotation (LCF) can vary, measured from the midship or aft perpendicular. Surveyors must grasp the ship's documentation and sign conventions to avoid errors.
It is important to be able to explain the +/- sign convention used in the ship's documentation to the surveyor and to detect if an error was made.
Detecting and Avoiding Errors
To reduce draft survey errors, surveyors should follow certain guidelines:
Ensure the correct trim and water density are used from the ship's hydrostatic tables.
Use the correct draft measurement for calculations.
Employ the same hydrometer for both initial and final surveys to avoid inconsistencies.
Double-check all calculations and corrections to spot any mistakes.
After all corrections are applied, all parties should agree on the corrected displacement. This agreement prevents disputes and ensures accurate cargo weight determination.
Type of Correction | Purpose |
Trim Correction | Accounts for the difference in draft readings at the forward and aft perpendiculars |
Density Correction | Adjusts for the difference between the actual water density and the standard density used in the hydrostatic tables |
Hog/Sag Correction | Compensates for the vessel's deflection along its length due to uneven loading or structural issues |
By grasping ship-specific documentation, spotting and avoiding errors, and accurately applying corrections, surveyors can ensure reliable draft survey calculations. This is key for accurate cargo weight determination and dispute prevention.
Documenting Evidence and Resolving Disputes
Accurate draft survey documentation is vital for resolving disputes over cargo weight and quantity.
In case of a dispute, all relevant parties should discuss and record the issues. It's essential to compare any shortage claims on a like-for-like basis. This approach avoids unfair comparisons between shore scale measurements and draft survey results.
A comprehensive written report should also be prepared, detailing the entire draft survey process. This report should include all calculations, corrections applied, and the final displacement figures. By maintaining thorough draft survey documentation, stakeholders can effectively resolve disputes and ensure fair and accurate cargo weight determination.
Proper documentation is the key to resolving draft survey disputes and protecting the interests of all parties involved in the cargo transportation process.
By following best practices for documenting draft survey evidence and establishing clear contractual terms, carriers, shippers, and other stakeholders can minimize the risk of disputes. This ensures smooth, efficient cargo operations.
Conclusion
Accurate ship draft surveys are crucial for cargo loading quantities. This ship draft survey guide helps surveyors achieve precise measurements. It's important to grasp concepts like lightship weight and variability to ensure accurate draft surveys.
Preparation, calibrated equipment, and error minimization are key steps. Surveyors must follow draft survey best practices for reliable results. This includes calculating ballast and applying corrections.
Clear documentation and contractual terms prevent disputes in cargo transactions. Accurate surveys ensure fair billing and compliance with maritime laws. By consistently delivering precise measurements, surveyors are essential for smooth operations and trust in the maritime industry.
FAQ
What is the purpose of conducting a ship draft survey?
Ship draft surveys aim to accurately measure cargo by calculating the vessel's displacement. This ensures fair trade and prevents disputes among ship owners, charterers, and other stakeholders.
What is the principle behind draft surveys?
Draft surveys rely on Archimedes' principle, which equates the weight of a floating object to the fluid it displaces. By measuring displacement before and after loading, the cargo's weight is determined.
What are some key concepts and definitions related to draft surveys?
Key concepts include lightship weight, constant, hogging, and sagging. Lightship weight is the ship's weight without cargo or fuel. Constant is the difference between calculated and tabular lightship weight. Hogging and sagging refer to uneven weight distribution in the ship.
What equipment is needed to conduct a ship draft survey?
Essential tools include a strong torch, draught mark indicators, and measuring devices. An inclinometer or manometer, steel tape measures, and a bucket for seawater sampling are also necessary. Additionally, a hydrometer, refractometer, ballast water sampling device, and a computer/calculator are required.
How can parallax error be minimized when reading draft marks?
To reduce parallax error, read draft marks close to the waterline, possibly from a boat. Surveyors should note metre marks mentally and ensure draft marks are evenly spaced for accurate calculations.
What is the step-by-step process for conducting a ship draft survey?
The process involves observing six drafts and measuring water density. Calculate mean drafts and perpendiculars, apply trim corrections, and use hydrostatic tables to determine displacement.
Why is accurate dock water density measurement important in draft surveys?
Accurate water density measurement is critical for precise calculations. Use calibrated hydrometers to avoid confusion. Water density can change rapidly due to rainfall or tidal forces, so sample at various locations and depths for an average value.
How can errors be detected and avoided in draft survey calculations?
Minimize errors by understanding ship documentation, ensuring correct trim and water density, and using consistent equipment. Pay attention to the +/- sign convention to detect errors.
What should be done in case of disputes during a draft survey?
Discuss and record any disputes. Video recordings and photos of draft readings are crucial in resolving disputes. Clearly specify acceptable figures in the charter party to prevent issues.
Source Links
Draft Survey Calculation and Reports, PDF | Britannia P&I - https://britanniapandi.com/2023/12/draft-survey/
All You Wanted to Know About Draft Survey Calculations - MySeaTime - https://www.myseatime.com/blog/detail/here-is-all-you-wanted-to-know-about-draft-survey-calculations
PDF - https://marplat.eu/pluginfile.php/1835/mod_folder/content/0/Draft survey operation/Draft survey operation TUTORIAL.pdf?forcedownload=1
What is a Draft Survey and Why Does It Matter in Shipping ? - https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/what-draft-survey-why-does-matter-shipping-istow-loading-computer-jhc0c
Draft Survey Defence of Dry Bulk Cargo Short Delivery Claims - Maritime Mutual - https://maritime-mutual.com/risk-bulletins/draft-survey-defence-of-dry-bulk-cargo-short-delivery-claims/
Draft Survey Inspection Services and Procedures - http://www.cotecna.com/en/media/news/draft-survey-inspection-services-and-procedures
Draft Survey Explained | In-Depth Guide to Draft Survey | Shipping and Cargo Inspection - https://ruswalglobal.com/what-is-the-purpose-of-a-draft-survey-/
Draft Survey.pptx - https://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/draft-surveypptx/262530258
Conducting Effective Draft Surveys: UN Guidelines - https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/conducting-effective-draft-surveys-un-guidelines-martín-ruiz-diaz-blwqf
Draught Surveying - https://www.lloydmaritime.com/C-C/draught-surveying
Vessel Draft Survey Accuracy - https://thenavalarch.com/vessel-draft-survey-accuracy/
Marine Surveyor InformationDraft Survey: Procedures and Calculation - https://sevensurveyor.com/draft-survey-procedures-and-calculation/
The Correct Use of Marine Hydrometers | U.S Marine Survey - https://usmarinesurvey.com/blog-detail/the-correct-use-of-marine-hydrometers
Inaccuracies in Draught Surveys - https://www.westpandi.com/news-and-resources/loss-prevention-bulletins/inaccuracies-in-draught-surveys/
What Is Draft or Draught Of A Ship? - https://www.marineinsight.com/naval-architecture/vessel-draft-vessel-draught-ship/
Draft Survey | Knowledge Of Sea - https://knowledgeofsea.com/draft-survey/
Draught Survey - Observater Surveys and Services Limited - https://observater.com/draught-survey/
Liquid Cargo Measurement: Ullage, Sounding & Draft Survey - https://marlinblue.com/liquid-cargo-measurement-ullage-sounding-amp-draft-survey/
The Role of the Bill of Lading (BL) in Bulk Cargo Shortage Disputes - Marlin Blue - https://marlinblue.com/the-role-of-the-bill-of-lading-bl-in-bulk-cargo-shortage-disputes/
Ensuring Accurate Cargo Measurement | U.S Marine Survey - https://usmarinesurvey.com/blog-detail/ensuring-accurate-cargo-measurement
Many faces of survey equipment failures during marine research at sea—Risk analysis - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9422978/
Glossary of Maritime Terms - https://www.aapa-ports.org/advocating/content.aspx?ItemNumber=21500
Comments