Have you ever thought about what happens to ships when they reach the end of their operational life? This question opens up the complex world of ship recycling, a crucial process for sustainable maritime practices. Ship recycling involves dismantling vessels and repurposing their parts.
Although vital, this industry has faced challenges due to dangerous conditions and environmental impacts. The Hong Kong Convention and IMO standards play a key role in establishing guidelines for safe and environmentally responsible ship recycling worldwide.
Ship recycling is crucial for managing vessels at the end of their life cycle, following the "cradle to grave" philosophy. When done correctly, it allows for the reuse of almost all materials and equipment, making it both environmentally friendly and energy-efficient. For example, recycling steel requires much less energy than producing steel from raw materials.
However, the differences in working conditions and environmental standards at ship recycling facilities highlight the need for global regulations to ensure consistent safety and environmental protections.
The Hong Kong International Convention for the Safe and Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships, adopted in 2009, is set to come into effect on June 26, 2025.
This important convention establishes a framework for ship dismantling, addressing worker safety, environmental protection, and the effective management of hazardous materials. The convention will be activated once it is ratified by at least 15 states, representing 40% of global merchant shipping by gross tonnage, and a combined annual ship recycling volume of at least 3% of the gross tonnage of the ratifying states' merchant fleets.
Key Takeaways
Ship recycling is a sustainable approach to managing end-of-life vessels, yet it has been linked to hazardous working conditions and environmental issues.
The Hong Kong Convention and IMO standards aim to guarantee safe, environmentally responsible ship recycling practices worldwide.
The Hong Kong Convention lays down a framework for the safe, sustainable dismantling of ships, focusing on worker safety, environmental conservation, and the proper management of hazardous materials.
The convention's activation criteria necessitate ratification by at least 15 states, representing 40% of the world's merchant shipping by gross tonnage, and a combined maximum annual ship recycling volume of not less than 3% of the gross tonnage of the ratifying states' merchant shipping.
IMO's Marine Environment Protection Committee has formulated guidelines for ship recycling, encompassing ship recycling plans, the authorization of ship recycling facilities, and the Inventory of Hazardous Materials.
Introduction to Ship Recycling
Ship recycling, also known as ship breaking or ship demolition, entails the dismantling of vessels at the end of their life to extract valuable materials and dispose of hazardous waste responsibly. The average age of a ship destined for demolition ranges from 20 to 32 years, influenced by vessel type, freight market conditions, and the demand from scrapyards.
The Importance of Safe and Environmentally Sound Ship Recycling
Ensuring that ship recycling is both safe and environmentally responsible is crucial to reducing the dangers posed by hazardous materials such as asbestos, heavy metals, hydrocarbons, and substances that deplete the ozone layer. This requires strict compliance with worker safety protocols and hazardous waste management procedures to protect human health and the environment.
The Hong Kong Convention assigns ship owners the duty of monitoring ship components, requiring recycling at facilities that meet certain standards.
Current Practices and Challenges in the Ship Recycling Industry
According to UNCTAD data, Bangladesh, India, and Pakistan lead in ship scrapping by tonnage. Ship recycling employs various methods including dry docking, pier breaking, landing/slipway, and beaching. Yet, the industry faces challenges in maintaining uniform environmental standards and worker safety across different yards.
Ship Component | Percentage |
Mild Steel (M.S.) | 95% |
Stainless Steel | 2% |
Miscellaneous Metals (Brass, Aluminum, Copper, Alloys) | 3% |
Recent regulatory advancements, including the IMO Hong Kong Convention and the EU Ship Recycling Regulation, have enhanced ship demolition standards, prioritizing safety and environmental sustainability. Ship recycling facilities must submit a 'Ship Recycling Plan' outlining the recycling process, considering the vessel's characteristics and hazardous material inventory. China's 2018 ban on foreign ships for recycling has significantly impacted the industry.
The Hong Kong Convention regulates ship recycling by requiring initial, periodic, and final surveys before recycling, with ships needing to carry Inventories of Hazardous Materials (IHM) onboard and recycling facilities providing ship recycling plans.
Despite these advancements, challenges persist in ensuring uniform implementation of worker safety protocols and hazardous waste handling procedures across all ship recycling facilities globally.
The Hong Kong Convention
The Hong Kong International Convention for the Safe and Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships, adopted in 2009, addresses the pressing issues of ship breaking and environmental compliance. It ensures that ships nearing the end of their service are recycled safely and with environmental responsibility. This approach minimizes health risks and environmental damage.
Objectives and Key Provisions of the Hong Kong Convention in Ship Recycling
The Hong Kong Convention lays out a detailed framework for recycling ships safely and sustainably. Its primary goals are:
Ensuring ships headed for recycling do not pose risks to human health, safety, and the environment
Creating a certification and authorization system for recycling facilities
Advancing environmentally sound practices in ship recycling
Fostering cooperation among ship owners, recycling facilities, and authorities for compliance
Key aspects of the convention include:
Ships must have an Inventory of Hazardous Materials (IHM)
Recycling facilities must develop a Ship Recycling Plan (SRP)
Setting up surveys and certifications to meet the convention's standards
Entry into Force Criteria and Current Status
The Hong Kong Convention will take effect 24 months after certain conditions are fulfilled:
At least 15 states must ratify the convention
The combined merchant fleets of ratifying states must account for not less than 40% of global shipping tonnage
The ratifying states' combined annual ship recycling volume over the past 10 years must be at least 3% of their combined merchant shipping tonnage
By June 2023, the convention's entry-into-force criteria were met, with 22 contracting states ratifying it. These states represent about 80% of the global ship recycling market. The convention is expected to come into effect on 25 June 2025.
Milestone | Date |
Adoption of the Hong Kong Convention | May 2009 |
Entry-into-force conditions met | June 2023 |
Scheduled entry into force | 25 June 2025 |
The Hong Kong Convention's entry into force is a crucial step towards global sustainable and responsible ship recycling. It ensures safer working conditions and better environmental protection in the ship breaking industry.
IMO Guidelines for Safe and Environmentally Sound Ship Recycling
The International Maritime Organization (IMO) has crafted a set of guidelines to aid in the implementation of the Hong Kong Convention. These guidelines aim to ensure safe and environmentally sound ship recycling practices. Adopted by the Marine Environment Protection Committee, they cover the ship recycling process comprehensively. This ensures the technical standards of the Convention are applied effectively.
The Ship Recycling Plan is a pivotal aspect of the IMO guidelines. It acts as a blueprint for the recycling process, outlining the steps and procedures for dismantling a ship safely and responsibly. The guidelines offer a framework for developing a detailed Ship Recycling Plan. This takes into account the vessel's unique characteristics and the recycling facility's specific requirements.
The Inventory of Hazardous Materials (IHM) is another crucial element addressed by the guidelines. This document identifies and quantifies hazardous materials onboard a ship, aiding recycling facilities in their safe handling and disposal. The guidelines provide guidance on preparing, maintaining, and verifying the IHM. This ensures it remains accurate and current throughout the ship's lifecycle.
"The IMO guidelines play a vital role in promoting safe and environmentally sound ship recycling practices, providing a clear framework for the implementation of the Hong Kong Convention's technical standards." - Dr. Stefan Micallef, Director of the Marine Environment Division at IMO
The guidelines also focus on the survey and certification of ships and the inspection and authorization of ship recycling facilities. These measures ensure that both ships and recycling facilities meet the required standards for safe and environmentally sound recycling. This promotes transparency and accountability in the recycling process.
These guidelines facilitate the early and voluntary adoption of the Hong Kong Convention's provisions, even before its official entry into force. By embracing these guidelines, states and industry stakeholders can enhance ship recycling practices. This minimizes environmental and occupational health and safety risks associated with dismantling end-of-life vessels.
As the maritime industry evolves and the demand for sustainable ship recycling increases, the IMO guidelines will continue to be essential. By adhering to these guidelines and implementing the Hong Kong Convention's provisions collaboratively, the global shipping community can strive towards a more responsible and sustainable future for ship recycling.
Requirements for Ships Under the Hong Kong Convention
The Hong Kong Convention establishes a comprehensive framework to ensure that ships are recycled in a safe, environmentally sound, and sustainable manner. This framework includes several key requirements that ships must meet throughout their operational life and during the recycling process.
Inventory of Hazardous Materials (IHM)
Under the Hong Kong Convention, all ships of 500 gross tonnage and above must carry an inventory of hazardous materials (IHM) on board. The IHM is a crucial document that identifies the location and approximate quantities of hazardous materials present in the ship's structure and equipment. This information is essential for the safe handling and disposal of these materials during the recycling process.
The IHM must be maintained and updated throughout the ship's operational life, ensuring that any changes in the hazardous materials on board are accurately recorded. The Convention requires that the IHM be verified by the ship's flag state or a recognized organization before the ship can be recycled.
Surveys and Certification
To ensure compliance with the Hong Kong Convention, ships must undergo a series of ship surveys throughout their operational life. These surveys include an initial survey, annual surveys, and a final survey prior to recycling. The purpose of these surveys is to verify that the ship's IHM is maintained and updated and that the ship is in compliance with the Convention's requirements.
Upon successful completion of the surveys, the ship will be issued a certificate of compliance, which is valid for a period of five years. This certificate serves as proof that the ship meets the requirements of the Hong Kong Convention and is eligible for recycling at an authorized ship recycling facility.
Authorization of Ship Recycling Facilities
The Hong Kong Convention requires that ship recycling facilities be authorized by their respective national authorities before they can accept ships for recycling. To obtain authorization, these facilities must demonstrate that they have the necessary infrastructure, equipment, and procedures in place to ensure the safe and environmentally sound recycling of ships.
Authorized ship recycling facilities must also develop and implement a ship recycling plan for each ship they intend to recycle. This plan outlines the specific steps and procedures that will be followed during the recycling process, taking into account the unique characteristics of the ship and the hazardous materials present on board.
Ship Recycling Plan
The ship recycling plan is a critical component of the Hong Kong Convention's framework for safe and environmentally sound ship recycling. This plan must be developed by the ship recycling facility in consultation with the ship owner and must be approved by the competent authority of the recycling state.
The ship recycling plan must include detailed information on the recycling process, including the methods and procedures to be used for the removal and disposal of hazardous materials, the measures to be taken to protect the health and safety of workers, and the steps to be taken to prevent pollution of the environment.
Worker Safety and Training
Worker safety and training are paramount in the ship recycling industry. The Hong Kong Convention requires that ship recycling facilities provide their workers with the necessary training and equipment to carry out their duties safely and effectively. This includes training on the proper handling and disposal of hazardous materials, the use of personal protective equipment, and emergency response procedures.
The Hong Kong Convention's focus on worker safety and training is a critical step towards ensuring that the ship recycling industry operates in a manner that protects the health and well-being of its workers while also safeguarding the environment.
By adhering to the requirements set forth in the Hong Kong Convention, ships and ship recycling facilities can play a vital role in promoting sustainable and responsible practices in the maritime industry.
The Role of Flag States, Port States, and Recycling States
The Hong Kong Convention for the Safe and Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships (HKC) delineates distinct responsibilities for flag states, port states, and recycling states. This Convention, poised to become effective on June 26, 2025, necessitates a comprehensive understanding of these roles. Such comprehension is vital for the advancement of sustainable ship recycling methodologies.
Flag states are instrumental in ensuring compliance with the Convention's stipulations for vessels under their jurisdiction. They undertake surveys, issue certificates, and approve the Inventory of Hazardous Materials (IHM) for each ship. Furthermore, they must verify that ships earmarked for recycling possess a valid International Ready for Recycling Certificate (IRRC) prior to such disposal.
Port states wield the authority to inspect vessels at their ports for adherence to the Convention. Through this port state control, they ascertain that ships hold a valid IHM and IRRC, and operate in accordance with the Convention's mandates. Port states are empowered to detect and report any infractions of the Convention to the flag state and the IMO.
Recycling states are obligated to ensure that ship recycling facilities within their jurisdiction adhere to the Hong Kong Convention. They must endorse ship recycling facilities and conduct routine inspections to ascertain compliance with the Convention's benchmarks for safe and environmentally benign recycling. Recycling states are also tasked with guaranteeing that ship recycling facilities possess effective waste management systems and that personnel are adequately trained and equipped to manage hazardous materials.
Country | Ship Recycling Capacity (LDT) | Hong Kong Convention Status |
Bangladesh | 6,500,000 | Party |
India | 4,500,000 | Party |
Türkiye | 1,000,000 | Party |
China | 8,000,000 | Not a Party |
The table illustrates that Bangladesh, India, and Türkiye, among the top five ship recycling nations, are signatories to the Hong Kong Convention. This underscores their dedication to fostering safe and environmentally responsible ship recycling. Conversely, China and Pakistan, despite their substantial ship recycling capacities, remain non-signatories to the Convention.
Through concerted efforts and adherence to their duties under the Hong Kong Convention, flag states, port states, and recycling states can significantly contribute to the establishment of a sustainable ship recycling sector. This sector must prioritize both human health and environmental protection. As the need for ship recycling intensifies, it is imperative that all stakeholders remain committed to the Convention's mandates and advocate for exemplary practices within the industry.
Environmental and Occupational Health and Safety Risks in Ship Recycling
The ship recycling industry is vital for the sustainable management of end-of-life vessels, yet it poses significant environmental and occupational health risks. Ships contain hazardous materials like asbestos, heavy metals, and hydrocarbons, which, if not handled properly, can contaminate the environment and pose health hazards to workers.
In countries such as India, Bangladesh, and Pakistan, where a substantial part of ship recycling occurs, workers frequently lack adequate protective gear and training. This deficiency heightens the risk of occupational accidents and exposure to perilous substances. The 1989 Basel Convention categorizes most shipboard substances as hazardous and toxic, emphasizing the imperative for stringent regulations and safety protocols.
Ship-recycling workers in countries like India, Bangladesh, and Pakistan often lack proper protective equipment and training, increasing the risk of occupational accidents.
Despite the formidable challenges, there is ongoing progress in mitigating environmental risks and enhancing occupational health and safety within the ship recycling sector. The Hong Kong International Convention, ratified in 2009, sets forth global standards for ship recycling, ensuring safe and environmentally sound practices. It mandates ship recycling facilities to adopt measures that safeguard human health and the environment, including:
Worker safety and training programs
Emergency preparedness and response plans
Monitoring and reporting systems
International conventions aside, some ship recycling facilities are proactively enhancing working conditions and reducing environmental risks.
Country | Regular Employee Literacy Rate | Regular Employee Average Monthly Income | Non-Regular Employee Literacy Rate | Non-Regular Employee Average Monthly Income |
India | 89% | 28,706tk | 53% | 21,418tk |
Bangladesh (PHP Ship Recycling Facility) | - | Above 19,255tk (living wage) | - | - |
As the maritime industry advances, it is imperative that ship recycling practices evolve to meet the increasing demand for sustainable and responsible vessel disposal. By tackling environmental risks, prioritizing occupational health and safety, and ensuring the proper management of hazardous materials, the ship recycling industry can contribute to a sustainable future for the maritime sector and the communities it affects.
Green Ship Recycling and the Circular Economy
The ship recycling industry is integral to the circular economy, ensuring that end-of-life ships' materials are reused and recycled. This approach minimizes waste and conserves virgin resources. Green ship recycling emphasizes the safe and environmentally responsible dismantling of vessels, following international standards and best practices.
Best Practices in Sustainable Ship Dismantling
Sustainable ship dismantling focuses on best practices that ensure worker safety, environmental care, and material recovery. Important aspects include:
Proper management and disposal of hazardous materials like asbestos, PCBs, and heavy metals
Use of environmentally friendly dismantling methods, such as dry dock or pier-side dismantling
Implementation of comprehensive worker safety and training programs
Maximizing the reuse and recycling of materials, including steel, machinery, and equipment
Compliance with international and national regulations, such as the Hong Kong Convention and the EU Ship Recycling Regulation
Approximately 30% of global steel production originates from scrap steel, underscoring the significant contribution of ship recycling to the circular economy.
The EU Ship Recycling Regulation
The European Union has established a unique regulatory framework for ship recycling, which complements the Hong Kong Convention. This framework, known as the Ship Recycling Regulation (EU SRR), was adopted by the European Parliament and the Council of the European Union on 20 November 2013. It encourages the early ratification of the Hong Kong Convention by enforcing controls on ships and recycling facilities that align with the convention's standards.
As of 31 December 2018, commercial vessels flying the EU flag with a gross tonnage of 500 GT or more are required to be recycled in facilities that guarantee safety and environmental sustainability. These facilities must be included on the European List of approved ship recycling facilities, which was introduced on 19 December 2016, and comprises facilities located in the EU, Turkey, and the US.
Key Differences Between the EU Regulation and the Hong Kong Convention
Although the EU Ship Recycling Regulation is modeled after the Hong Kong Convention, there are significant distinctions. A primary difference lies in the requirement that EU-flagged vessels must be recycled in facilities listed on the European List. These facilities must adhere to stringent standards, ensuring enhanced safety and environmental safeguards.
Another distinction is the EU's demand for an Inventory of Hazardous Materials (IHM) on European ships and those under third-country flags visiting EU ports.
This inventory facilitates the identification and management of hazardous materials throughout the ship's life cycle, fostering safer and more eco-friendly recycling processes.
EU Ship Recycling Regulation | Hong Kong Convention |
Applies to EU-flagged commercial vessels above 500 GT | Applies to ships of 500 GT and above, regardless of flag |
Requires recycling in approved facilities listed in the European List | Allows recycling in authorized facilities that meet convention standards |
Mandates IHM for European ships and third-country vessels calling at EU ports | Requires IHM for ships, but does not specify requirements for third-country vessels |
Despite their differences, the EU Ship Recycling Regulation and the Hong Kong Convention converge on the goal of ensuring safe and environmentally responsible ship recycling. Through cooperation and harmonization, these frameworks can enhance the ship recycling industry's standards. This, in turn, minimizes the adverse effects on human health and the environment.
Future Trends and Challenges in the Ship Recycling Industry
The shipbreaking industry is advancing with technological innovations such as robotics, automation, and digitalization, focusing on sustainable methods, environmental responsibility, and worker safety.
Despite these advancements, the industry faces several challenges that require attention for a sustainable future. These challenges include:
The need for infrastructure improvements in developing countries to promote green ship recycling practices
Building capacity and providing training to develop a skilled workforce in sustainable ship recycling
Ensuring the proper enforcement of regulations and standards to prevent harmful practices like beaching
Adapting to the increasing number of End-of-Life (EoL) ships as the global fleet ages
Key Statistics | Figures |
World merchandise trade by volume carried by maritime ships | Over 80% |
World fleet carrying capacity in 2020 | 2.1 billion dwt |
Average service life of a vessel | Around 30 years |
Large oceangoing vessels sold for dismantling in 2019 | More than 800 (over 14 million gross tons) |
Share of world's oceangoing vessels dismantled in India, Bangladesh, and Pakistan | 70%-80% |
To navigate these challenges and seize future opportunities, the ship recycling industry must forge partnerships with stakeholders, including shipowners, maritime consultants, and regulatory entities. By embracing circular economy principles, investing in green technologies, and prioritizing worker safety and environmental stewardship, the industry can forge a path towards a sustainable and responsible future in ship recycling.
Conclusion
The Hong Kong Convention and IMO standards have established a framework for a safer, more environmentally sound ship recycling industry. This framework, despite a 15-year ratification journey, offers a holistic solution to the intricate issues surrounding ship recycling. Regional disparities, such as South Asian countries' non-endorsement of the Basel Ban Amendment, present challenges. Yet, the HKC stands as a crucial rule, ensuring uniformity, adherence, and streamlined environmental and safety oversight.
The industry's growth, with over 15,000 ships slated for recycling in the next decade, brings forth capacity and retrofitting challenges. Regulations like the Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII) and Energy Efficiency Existing Ship Index (EEXI) intensify these issues. The EU Ship Recycling Regulation (EU SRR) mandates an Inventory of Hazardous Materials (IHM), underscoring the imperative for a unified standard. However, European List yards' limited capacity for large ships and the EU SRR's enforcement complexities for non-European flagged vessels highlight the necessity for global cooperation and standardization.
Looking ahead, the ship recycling sector must prioritize safety and environmental sustainability, relying on the Hong Kong Convention and IMO's guidelines. Collaboration with maritime consultants, adoption of sustainable dismantling best practices, and a circular economy approach are essential. These strategies will help the industry navigate future hurdles, aiming for a greener, more accountable ship recycling future globally.
FAQ
What is ship recycling?
Ship recycling dismantles vessels at their operational conclusion to reclaim and reuse materials like steel, equipment, and components. It's vital for the maritime industry's circular economy, ensuring efficient resource use and minimizing waste.
Why is safe and environmentally sound ship recycling important?
Ensuring ship recycling is safe and environmentally responsible is paramount for human health, environmental conservation, and fostering sustainable maritime practices. Inadequate recycling can lead to hazardous material release, pollution, and health risks for workers.
What is the Hong Kong Convention?
Adopted in 2009, the Hong Kong International Convention for the Safe and Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships sets global standards for sustainable ship recycling. It mandates a regulatory framework for recycling, focusing on worker safety, environmental safeguards, and hazardous material management.
When will the Hong Kong Convention enter into force?
The Hong Kong Convention will commence on 26 June 2025, following a 24-month countdown from June 2023. By January 2024, 24 nations had ratified it, accounting for about 45.91% of global merchant shipping tonnage.
What is the Inventory of Hazardous Materials (IHM)?
The IHM is a critical element under the Hong Kong Convention. It details and quantifies hazardous materials onboard, such as asbestos and heavy metals. Maintaining and updating the IHM is crucial for planning eco-friendly and safe ship recycling.
What are the responsibilities of flag states, port states, and recycling states under the Hong Kong Convention?
Flag states must ensure their vessels comply with the Convention, including maintaining IHMs and undergoing surveys. Port states inspect ships for adherence to the Convention. Recycling states oversee ship recycling facilities, ensuring they meet safety and environmental standards.
What are the best practices in sustainable ship dismantling?
Sustainable ship dismantling involves proper hazardous material handling, eco-friendly dismantling methods, robust worker safety training, and material reuse and recycling. Following the Hong Kong Convention and IMO guidelines is key to green ship recycling.
How can maritime consultants assist in compliance with ship recycling regulations?
Maritime consultants are vital in aiding shipowners, recycling facilities, and stakeholders with Hong Kong Convention compliance. They provide expertise in IHM development, Ship Recycling Plans, and training on best practices for safe, eco-friendly ship recycling.
Source Links
Recycling of ships - https://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Environment/Pages/Ship-Recycling.aspx
Ship Recycling Convention (the Hong Kong Convention) | ClassNK - https://www.classnk.or.jp/hp/en/activities/statutory/shiprecycle/index.html
Ship Recycling Industry - http://shipsbusiness.com/ship-recycling-industry.html
EU Ship Recycling Regulation - NGO Shipbreaking Platform - https://shipbreakingplatform.org/issues-of-interest/the-law/eu-srr/
Scrapping of ships - https://www.sdir.no/en/shipping/vessels/environment/scrapping-of-ships/
PDF - https://www.shiprecyclingtransparency.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2020/07/SRTI-2020-Report-V7.pdf
UN accord on ship recycling to start within two years - https://www.demolitionandrecycling.media/news/un-accord-on-ship-recycling-to-start-within-two-years/8029971.article
Trading Lives for Profit - https://www.hrw.org/report/2023/09/28/trading-lives-profit/how-shipping-industry-circumvents-regulations-scrap-toxic
How Ship Dismantling is Done? - https://www.marineinsight.com/guidelines/how-ship-dismantling-is-done/
What is the life cycle of large ships? (1) - https://www.mol-service.com/blog/ship-recycling-1
Green Seas: India gets impatient as ship recycling treaty ratification nears - https://www.tradewindsnews.com/esg/green-seas-india-gets-impatient-as-ship-recycling-treaty-ratification-nears/2-1-1471120
LL_PROOF_080312 - https://www.ukpandi.com/media/files/imports/13108/news/9663-shiprecyclingspecialfeature_lizmccarthy.pdf
elni_2012-2_Ormond - https://www.elni.org/elni/elni-review/archive/elni-2012-2-ormond
Ship Demolition: Practical Issues and Considerations - JTJB - https://jtjb.com/law-bites-july-2020/
Ship recycling – Norwegian Appeals Court explores the limits of individual shipowner responsibility - https://gard.no/articles/ship-recycling-norwegian-appeals-court-explores-limits-individual-shipowner-responsibility/
Where ships go to die - Winner of the Public Eye Investigation Award - NGO Shipbreaking Platform - https://shipbreakingplatform.org/spotlight-swiss-focus/
data Archives - NGO Shipbreaking Platform - https://shipbreakingplatform.org/tag/data/
PDF - https://www.elgaronline.com/downloadpdf/monochap-oa/book/9781035314683/book-part-9781035314683-8.pdf
PDF - https://shipbreakingplatform.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/NGO-SBP-Annual-Report-2020_2021.pdf
Human Rights Initiatives | NYK Line - https://www.nyk.com/english/esg/social/activities/
An assessment of development opportunities of ship recycling facilities based on the shipbuilding yards' infrastructures in Vietnam - https://commons.wmu.se/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2194&context=all_dissertations
Microsoft Word - Tsomaeva_Thesis_Sale of vessels for recycling.doc - https://www.duo.uio.no/bitstream/handle/10852/86926/1/8212.pdf
A Gap Analysis of Ship-Recycling Practices in Indonesia - https://www.mdpi.com/2313-4321/6/3/48
Comentarios